|
 
- UID
- 940
- 帖子
- 688
- 主题
- 22
- 精华
- 5
- 积分
- 1196
- 零花钱
- -208 元
- 阅读权限
- 120
- 在线时间
- 59 小时
  
|
介绍一篇关于同性恋理论/婚姻/连贯的角色刻画/S5结局的论文
http://www.livejournal.com/community/queerasfolkfans/2003206.html
作者对编剧颇为不满，谈了他的看法，单纯看论文价值并不高，有趣的是底下的讨论，各路英豪又来争执了一番，包括一些一直想要“干掉”C/L的顽强的M Fans（这些外国人偏激的程度在咱们的论坛上并非看不见，只是属性不同。另外他们大多特别的喜欢Randy Harrison，我有的时候怀疑已经超过了Hal Spark。）
其实，这篇文章之所以最后能引起了我的注意，是因为作者回帖中的这么两段话：
One of Brian's main traits has always been that he will drop everything else for priority #1. Right now, priority #1 is making Justin happy keeping Justin nearby because he's freaked out and doing so by making Justin happy and giving Justin what Justin thinks he wants for himself, and Brian is ignoring what both he and Justin actually need. It can't last. One of them is going to crumble. It's like the worst reason to get married, like those girls who sleep with their boyfriends to keep them, or think if they get pregnant they'll have to stay together.
Or that's what I think. I honestly can't tell WHAT Cowlip wants me to think about it. Am I supposed to believe it's weird and wrong? Am I supposed to think it's romantic? What really freaks me out, personally, are the people who think it IS romantic, who are sighing over Brian calling Justin his prince and so on.
Brian says "I would do anything, say anything, be anything, to make Justin happy." That's not love; that's desperation. And if Justin goes along with it, that's cruelty. Brian ought to be stronger than that.
我翻译一下这句话：
Brian说：“我愿意做任何事、说任何话、变成任何样子，只要能使Justin快乐。”这不是爱情，这是走投无路了。如果Justin接受了这种感情，那才叫残酷，Brian应该比现在更坚强。
And I don't find it romantic. Trying to fill up a hole in yourself with another person doesn't work, can never work.
先声明，我并不完全同意这个看法，只是从Justin 507之后的看来，他真的长大了，有了很独立、很成熟的思想和判断力，511拒绝第一次求婚虽然让我相当惊讶，不过也合情合理，我真的认为很多事过去就过去了，是对是错已经过去了，反反复复的并没有什么好处。我非常尊重Justin之后与Brian破镜重圆的决定，只是再多的机会也未必能解决问题。这只是我肤浅的人生观给我的视角，我不是不相信某些感情是可以坚固耐用的。只是我不相信、也不欣赏人们执著的尝试他们一错再错的决定。
所以我也认为Justin沉默良久的“OK”其实很残忍，而且绝望的感情在我眼里通常很浪漫，故事倒是挺有趣的，如果不太认真的话。
另外一段更有趣：
And I was quite upset with myself when I realized I was all OTPsquee over Brian and Justin, because it's true, watching a show through the lens of caring whether these two people are together is pathetic and does warp it. But it's more than just that, in this case- I have actual philosophical objections to the plotline and the message, and I think the message that they're pushing is warping the story. Cowlip are allowing their desire to make a political point and their stress over having to FINISHUPTHEFIRSTGAYTVSHOWEVAROMG on a big huge note take over from concerns of plot and character consistency. It's not just B/J marriage- it's Mel and Linds running off to Canada, and Babylon getting blowed up, and Michael losing his spleen, and Ben and Michael not arguing anymore now that they're married (except over their children), and so on and on and on... It strikes me as forced. Over the top. And fuck, I was IN Virginia when I saw the prop 14 get introduced on the show (I watch it at my friends's house, she's in VA and I'm in MD) and believe me, I think the VA law is stupid, but have they brought up any of the appropriate concerns on the show? Like the blatant unconstitutionality of it? No, it's all "ZOMG Nazis did this too" and "Oh Canada!" And I love Canada, but it's not perfect.
C/L发动群众表达政见的时候你总是能感觉到众人都很盲目，就好像一群复员兵，一听敌人打来了，立刻扛上钢枪、奔赴战场一样。
我个人觉得通常人们的政治观点、或者政治信仰非常容易受到自身的身份的影响，比如种族，比如性向，这经常造成了他们对很多政治观点也比较盲目，很容易一拥而上，无论是支持还是反对，我这不是指QAF，因为那个该死的“14”确实剥夺了很多权利，我指的是QAF所展现的社会对立，我认为他们在S5中表现得有点过头了，尤其是巴比伦爆炸之后并没有展现太多社会中人道主义的部分，还有社会谅解的部分，他们依旧在强调分歧和仇视，比如Micahel的守夜活动，这种做法让我想到了S3里面对于渎职的警察局长的处理，我74%认为C/L的政见并不像他们故事中表现得那样幼稚，我只是觉得他们某些强烈的标志性炸弹也许无法起到他们想要起到的作用。
另外即使我非常喜欢Mel，也觉得她把她遇到的恐怖事件与纳粹的恶行对比太牵强了，林肯解放了黑奴之后不是没有3K党，但是美国并没有变成法西斯国家，加拿大去也不是什么“理想中的家园”，她们可以离开匹兹堡，但并非一定要远赴加拿大，这么把美国与加拿大对立起来总让我想起南方公园，至少那是在发泄，在开玩笑，一个像QAF一样的故事应该把结局设计的更科学、更合理一点。
就这么多。
——模棱两可 |
|
